Peer Review Process
The Journal of Sustainable Learning and Development (JSLD) employs a rigorous and transparent peer review process designed to ensure that every article it publishes is scientifically sound, ethically conducted and clearly reported. All research articles, review articles, case reports and short communications are assessed by independent experts before a decision is made. Editorials and invited commentaries are evaluated by the editorial team and are labelled as such in the table of contents. No manuscript is accepted on the strength of a single review.
1. Submission and Initial Evaluation
- Every submission is examined by the editorial office, normally within seven days of receipt, for fit with the journal's scope, compliance with the Author Guidelines, a statement of ethical approval with the name of the approving committee and the approval number, written consent where any participant could be identified, and declarations of funding and competing interests.
- All manuscripts are screened for similarity using Turnitin before review, in accordance with the journal's Plagiarism Policy. A manuscript may be returned at this stage without external review; this is not a judgement on the quality of the science, and the authors are always told the reason.
2. Assignment to an Editor
- A manuscript that passes screening is assigned to a handling editor with expertise in its subject area, who is responsible for selecting reviewers, weighing their assessments and reaching a decision.
- An editor with any competing interest withdraws and the manuscript is reassigned. A competing interest includes being at the same institution as an author, having co-authored with an author within the past three years, a supervisory relationship in either direction, or any personal or financial interest in the outcome.
3. Peer Reviewer Selection
- Two or more independent reviewers are invited for each manuscript. Where the work is methodologically complex, crosses disciplines, or rests on a substantial statistical analysis, further reviewers may be invited, including a statistical reviewer.
- Reviewers are selected for subject expertise and are checked for competing interests before invitation. Reviewers at the same institution as any author, or who have collaborated with an author recently, are not used.
- Author-suggested reviewers may be considered but are never the only reviewers, and the editor is under no obligation to use them.
4. Double-Blind Review
- JSLD operates double-blind review. The identities of the authors are withheld from the reviewers and the identities of the reviewers are withheld from the authors.
- Anonymity is maintained in practice, not only in principle: authors upload a title page separately from the main manuscript, the manuscript file carries no names, affiliations, acknowledgements or funding details, self-citations are written in the third person, and document properties are cleared before the file is sent out.
- Reviewers assess each manuscript against:
- originality and the importance of the question addressed;
- soundness of the study design, methods and statistical analysis;
- whether the conclusions are supported by the data presented;
- clarity of the writing, tables and figures, and adherence to the relevant reporting guideline;
- ethical conduct, including approval, consent, registration and declarations.
5. Editorial Decision
- The handling editor weighs the reviews and reaches a decision. Reviews are advisory; the decision rests with the editor, who may seek a further opinion where reviewers disagree.
- Authors receive the full text of the reviewers' comments together with the decision.
- Decisions fall into four categories:
- Accept — no further change required;
- Minor revision — the issues raised can be addressed without new analysis;
- Major revision — substantial change is needed and the revised manuscript will normally be sent back to the reviewers;
- Reject — the work is outside scope, methodologically unsound, or the conclusions are not supported.
6. Revision and Resubmission
- Authors are asked to return a revised manuscript with a point-by-point response to every comment, stating where each change has been made, or giving reasons where a change has not been made.
- Three weeks are allowed for revision, extendable on request. An invitation to revise is not a promise of acceptance.
7. Final Acceptance and Publication
- On acceptance the manuscript is copy-edited and typeset, and proofs are sent to the corresponding author for approval.
- A Crossref DOI is registered under the prefix DOI-PREFIX, the full metadata record is deposited, and the article is published open access under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (CC BY 4.0).
8. Timeline
- Initial editorial screening — within 7 days of submission.
- Reviewer assessment returned — 21 days from accepting the invitation.
- First decision — approximately 6 weeks from submission.
- Author revision — 3 weeks allowed, extendable on request.
- Acceptance to publication — approximately 4 weeks.
- These are working targets rather than guarantees. Where a manuscript takes longer, for example because a reviewer withdraws late or a third opinion is needed, the corresponding author is told the reason and given a revised expectation.
9. Submissions from Editors and Editorial Board Members
- A manuscript submitted by an editor, a member of the editorial board, or a member of the publisher's staff is handled entirely by an independent editor who has no involvement with the authors.
- The submitting editor has no access to the submission record, no sight of the reviewers' identities, and no part in the decision. The proportion of such papers is monitored and kept low.
10. Confidentiality
- Manuscripts under review are confidential documents. Reviewers must not show them to or discuss them with others except as authorised by the editors, and must not retain copies after review.
- No part of a manuscript may be uploaded to a generative artificial intelligence tool or any other external service, as doing so places unpublished work outside the journal's control. Reviewers who wish to use such tools in preparing a report must decline the invitation instead.
11. Appeals and Complaints
- Authors who believe a decision was reached in error may appeal within 30 days, writing to the Editor-in-Chief with a point-by-point response to the reviewers' comments and a clear statement of why the decision should be reconsidered.
- The appeal is assessed by an editor who took no part in the original decision. The outcome of an appeal is final. Complaints about the conduct of the review process are handled under the journal's Publication Ethics policy.
12. Post-Publication
- Concerns raised about a published article are investigated following the relevant COPE flowcharts, however long after publication they are raised, and the authors are given the opportunity to respond before any conclusion is reached.
- Where the record needs correcting, the journal publishes a correction, an expression of concern or a retraction notice, linked to the original article. Retracted articles remain available and are clearly marked, so that the scholarly record stays intact.
JSLD is committed to a review process that is fair to authors, respectful of reviewers' time, and transparent to readers. Questions about the process, or about the handling of a particular manuscript, may be sent to the Editor-in-Chief at editor@jsldbd.com.