Publication Ethics
The Journal of Sustainable Learning and Development (JSLD) is committed to maintaining the highest standards of publication ethics. The policies set out below apply to every party involved in publishing with the journal — authors, editors, reviewers and the publisher, Bangladesh Center for Research and Planning (BCRP). They follow the Core Practices and guidance of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), the ICMJE Recommendations, and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing.
1. Responsibilities of Authors
1.1 Originality and Plagiarism
Authors must submit only original work. Where the work or words of others have been used, they must be appropriately cited and quoted. All submissions are screened with similarity detection software before peer review. Plagiarism in any form — including the reproduction of another author's work as one's own, copying substantial portions of a text without attribution, and claiming results from research conducted by others — constitutes unethical publishing behaviour and is unacceptable.
1.2 Redundant and Concurrent Publication
Manuscripts submitted to JSLD must not be under consideration elsewhere, and must not have been published previously in any language. Submitting the same manuscript to more than one journal concurrently is unethical. Secondary publication is acceptable only where it meets the conditions set out in the ICMJE Recommendations and both editors agree in writing.
1.3 Authorship
Authorship is limited to those who have made a substantial contribution to the work. JSLD applies the four ICMJE criteria; all four must be met. Each author must have made substantial contributions to conception or design, or to acquisition, analysis or interpretation of data; drafted the work or revised it critically for important intellectual content; approved the final version; and agreed to be accountable for all aspects of the work.
Those who contributed but do not meet all four criteria should be named in the Acknowledgements with their permission. Gift authorship, guest authorship and ghost authorship are forms of misconduct. The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that all named authors have seen and approved the submitted version.
Requests to add, remove or reorder authors after submission must be made in writing by the corresponding author, must state the reason, and must be accompanied by written confirmation from every author, including the one being added or removed.
1.4 Research Involving Human Participants
- Studies involving human participants, their data or their responses must have been approved by an appropriate institutional review board, ethics committee or equivalent authority. The manuscript must name the approving body and give the approval reference number and date.
- Informed consent must have been obtained from all participants, and the manuscript must state that it was obtained. Where participants are children or young people, consent must have been obtained from a parent or legal guardian, and assent from the child where they are old enough to give it.
- Research conducted in schools, colleges or other institutions must have had the permission of the institution as well as of the individuals taking part. Where a participant stands in a dependent relationship to the researcher — a student to a teacher, a teacher to a head — the manuscript must say how the risk of coercion was addressed.
- Where a study is reported without ethics approval, authors must explain why approval was not required and identify the body that confirmed this. The editors may decline a manuscript on ethical grounds even where formal approval was granted.
1.5 Anonymity and Identifiable Material
- Participants have a right to privacy that must not be breached. Identifying details — names, initials, student or staff numbers, and any image from which a person could be recognised — must be omitted unless the information is essential to the argument and the participant, or their parent or guardian, has given written informed consent for publication.
- Institutions have the same protection. Where naming a school, college or district could expose individuals or the institution to harm, use a pseudonym and describe the setting in general terms.
- Authors must retain consent documents and provide them to the editors on request. Anonymity cannot be achieved by masking the eye region of a photograph.
1.6 Registration and Reporting Standards
- Systematic reviews should be registered prospectively where a relevant registry exists, and the registration number given in the manuscript.
- Studies evaluating an intervention should follow the reporting standard appropriate to the design, and qualitative studies should follow COREQ or SRQR. The manuscript should name the standard it has followed.
- Where a study was pre-registered or followed a published protocol, say so and give the reference. Departures from the protocol must be reported and explained.
1.7 Conflicts of Interest
All authors must disclose any financial or personal relationship that could be perceived to influence the work — employment, consultancies, honoraria, paid expert testimony, patent applications, grants, stock ownership, and membership of advocacy groups. Sources of funding must be stated, together with the role of the funder in study design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, and the decision to submit. Where there is nothing to declare, the manuscript must say so explicitly.
1.8 Data and Reproducibility
Authors must retain the raw data underlying their findings and be prepared to provide it for editorial review. Every article must carry a Data Availability Statement saying where the data can be found, or stating the reason access is restricted. Fabrication and falsification of data, including the inappropriate manipulation of images, constitute serious misconduct.
1.9 Use of Artificial Intelligence Tools
Large language models and other generative artificial intelligence tools do not meet the criteria for authorship and must not be listed as authors, since they cannot take responsibility for the work. Where such tools have been used in the preparation of a manuscript, their use must be disclosed in the Methods or Acknowledgements, naming the tool and describing how it was used. Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality and integrity of everything they submit.
1.10 Errors in Published Work
When an author discovers a significant error in their own published article, they must notify the editors promptly and cooperate in issuing a correction or retraction.
2. Responsibilities of Editors
2.1 Publication Decisions
The Editor-in-Chief is responsible for deciding which submitted manuscripts are published. Decisions are based on the validity of the work, its importance to researchers and readers, and its fit with the journal's scope — never on the authors' nationality, institution, seniority, gender, ethnicity, religion or political beliefs.
2.2 Confidentiality
Editors must not disclose any information about a submitted manuscript to anyone other than the corresponding author, reviewers, potential reviewers, other editorial advisers and the publisher. Unpublished material disclosed in a submission must not be used in an editor's own research without the author's written consent.
2.3 Conflicts of Interest and Submissions from Editors
An editor must withdraw from handling any manuscript in which they have a competing interest, including manuscripts from their own institution, recent collaborators, or current students. Manuscripts submitted by an editor, a member of the editorial board, or the publisher's staff are handled entirely by an independent editor who has no involvement with the authors. The submitting editor has no access to the review record and takes no part in the decision. The proportion of such papers is monitored and kept low.
2.4 Vigilance over the Published Record
Editors will act whenever ethical concerns are raised about a submitted or published paper, even where those concerns are raised years after publication, and will take reasonable steps to identify and prevent publication of papers where research misconduct has occurred.
3. Responsibilities of Reviewers
3.1 Confidentiality
Manuscripts received for review are confidential documents. Reviewers must not show them to or discuss them with others except as authorised by the editors, must not retain copies after review, and must not upload any part of a manuscript to a generative artificial intelligence tool or other external service, as doing so places unpublished work outside the journal's control.
3.2 Objectivity and Standards
Reviews must be conducted objectively and must support their conclusions with argument and evidence. Personal criticism of authors is not acceptable. Reviewers should identify relevant published work that has not been cited, and should alert the editors to any substantial similarity between the manuscript and other published work of which they have knowledge.
3.3 Promptness and Conflicts
A reviewer who feels unqualified to assess a manuscript, who cannot complete the review within the agreed period, or who has a competing interest with any of the authors or institutions involved, must notify the editors promptly and decline the invitation. Privileged information obtained through review must not be used for personal advantage.
4. Misconduct, Corrections and Retractions
Allegations of misconduct — including plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, image manipulation, undisclosed conflicts of interest, authorship disputes, duplicate publication and unethical research conduct — are investigated following the relevant COPE flowcharts, whether the work is under consideration or already published.
The authors concerned are given the opportunity to respond before any conclusion is reached. Where a matter cannot be resolved with the authors, the editors may contact the authors' institution or funding body. Depending on the outcome, the journal may publish a correction, an expression of concern, or a retraction notice. Retraction notices are linked to the original article, state the reason for retraction, and identify who is retracting it. Retracted articles remain available and are clearly marked as retracted, so that the scholarly record stays intact.
5. Complaints and Appeals
Authors who believe an editorial decision was reached in error may appeal. Appeals should be sent to the Editor-in-Chief at the address below within 30 days of the decision, stating clearly why the decision should be reconsidered and responding point by point to the reviewers' comments. The appeal is assessed by an editor who was not involved in the original decision. The outcome of an appeal is final.
Complaints about editorial process, publication ethics, or the conduct of the journal's staff should be addressed to the Editor-in-Chief. Complaints are acknowledged within seven working days and resolved within 60 days. A complainant who is not satisfied with the outcome may escalate the matter to the publisher, Bangladesh Center for Research and Planning (BCRP).
6. Advertising and Commercial Influence
JSLD does not carry advertising. Editorial decisions are never influenced by commercial considerations, and the payment of an article processing charge plays no part in the peer review process or in the decision to accept or reject a manuscript. Direct marketing is limited to information about the journal and is never intrusive or misleading.
7. Contact
Ethical concerns, allegations of misconduct, complaints and appeals should be sent to the Editor-in-Chief . All correspondence is treated confidentially.